| Girls 1st Team All County | Girls 2nd Team All County | |||||
| 1 | Amanda Griggs (12) | Hilton | * | 29 | Christyna Cain (12) | Brockport |
| 2 | Caroline Shultz (11) | Hilton | * | 30 | Kelly Bartell (10) | Churchville-Chili |
| 3 | Allison Sawyer (11) | Hilton | * | 31 | Rachel Kahen (8) | Greece Athena |
| 4 | Katie Bower (12) | Pittsford Mendon | * | 32 | Julie Feola (12) | Greece Athena |
| 5 | Ashley Jones (10) | Hilton | * | 33 | Colleen Coon (9) | Penfield |
| 6 | Shelby Herman (10) | Hilton | * | 34 | Lauren Phillips (12) | Batavia |
| 7 | Jenna Bauer (11) | Spencerport | * | 35 | Angeleen Tauriello (9) | Gates-Chili |
| 8 | Shaylyn Tuite (7) | Pittsford Mendon | * | 36 | Kristine O'Connor (10) | Pittsford Sutherland |
| 9 | Brianna Deming (8) | Webster Thomas | * | 37 | Emily Davis (10) | Brockport |
| 10 | Julie Cass (10) | Fairport | * | 38 | Lauren Paffendorf (12) | Webster Schroeder |
| 11 | Amber Sanders (11) | Batavia | * | 39 | Jillian Weidman (9) | Penfield |
| 12 | Florence Williams (11) | Pittsford Sutherland | * | 40 | Sarah McAdam (9) | Irondequoit |
| 13 | Kate Cufari (10) | Pittsford Sutherland | * | 41 | Jan Kofsky (10) | Pittsford Sutherland |
| 14 | Nicole Varble (12) | Rush-Henrietta | * | 42 | Abby Taylor (11) | Pittsford Sutherland |
| 15 | Alyssa Smith (10) | Brighton | * | 43 | Chelsea Baldino (11) | Pittsford Sutherland |
| 16 | Emily Leary (11) | Brighton | * | 44 | Marla Woodarek (11) | Penfield |
| 17 | Melinda Sawnor (9) | Greece Athena | * | 45 | Jamie Varble (10) | Rush-Henrietta |
| 18 | Catherine Smith (11) | Brighton | * | 46 | Megan McKee (12) | Rush-Henrietta |
| 19 | Samantha Tucker (10) | Greece Arcadia | * | 47 | Laura Varble (10) | Rush-Henrietta |
| 20 | Morgan Atkins (7) | Pittsford Mendon | * | 48 | Margot Marquardt (10) | Pittsford Mendon |
| 21 | Karina Spicer (12) | Spencerport | * | 49 | Deanna Plucinik (12) | Batavia |
| 22 | Sandra Goettelman (12) | Spencerport | * | 50 | Caileen Childs (12) | Hilton |
| 23 | Lindsay Conway (12) | East Irondequoit | * | 51 | Sarah Haller (11) | Greece Arcadia |
| 24 | Jessie Wooten (12) | Rush-Henrietta | * | 52 | Carolyn D'Aprix (9) | Greece Arcadia |
| 25 | Amy Cymerman (8) | Pittsford Sutherland | * | 53 | Melanie Breslawski (12) | Brockport |
| 26 | Hilary Haefner (12) | Penfield | * | 54 | Nicole Griffiths (12) | Hilton |
| 27 | Ashley Cocuzzi (10) | Webster Schroeder | * | 55 | Samantha Howe (10) | Penfield |
| 28 | Christine White (12) | Rush-Henrietta | * | 56 | Angela Ryck (9) | Fairport |