| 1st Team All County | 2nd Team All County | |||
| Ashley Jones (9) | Hilton | * | Hilary Haefner (11) | Penfield |
| Allison Sawyer (10) | Hilton | * | Colleen Coon (8) | Penfield |
| Shelby Herman (9) | Hilton | * | Emily Leary (10) | Brighton |
| Lauren Ferrimani (12) | Fairport | * | Catherine Smith (10) | Brighton |
| Kate Cufari (9) | Pittsford Sutherland | * | Kelly Coulon (12) | Webster Thomas |
| Laura Iafrati (12) | Hilton | * | Brittany Hartmann (11) | Penfield |
| Laura Cass (12) | Fairport | * | Megan Anderson (12) | Fairport |
| Elizabeth Sweeney (12) | Rush Henrietta | * | Elisha Gielow (12) | Brighton |
| Karen Campbell (12) | Brighton | * | Julianna Feola (11) | Greece Athena |
| Kristen Bowers (12) | Greece Athena | * | Brittany Greco (9) | Pittsford Sutherland |
| Amber Sanders (10) | Batavia | * | Lauren Paffendorf (11) | Webster Schroeder |
| Emily Olsen (12) | Pittsford Sutherland | * | Alyssa Riehle (10) | Webster Thomas |
| Caroline Schultz (10) | Hilton | * | Deanna Plucinik (11) | Batavia |
| Nicole Varble (11) | Rush Henrietta | * | Veronica Griffiths (12) | Hilton |
| Kelly Bartell (9) | Churchville Chili | * | Shannon Bradley (11) | West Irondequoit |
| Jessica Schultz (12) | East Irondequoit | * | Laura Chernak (12) | Penfield |
| Jessie Wooten (11) | Rush Henrietta | * | Melinda Houle (10) | Greece Athena |
| Katie Elliot (12) | Penfield | * | Shannon Fee (10) | Pittsford Sutherland |
| Katie Bower (11) | Pittsford Mendon | * | Lisa Van Harken (12) | Webster Thomas |
| Karina Spicer (11) | Spencerport | * | Lindsay Davis (12) | Pittsford Mendon |
| Megan Goetz (12) | Fairport | * | Christina Cali (12) | Greece Athena |
| Monica Bhattacharjee (12) | Penfield | * | Megan Frame (10) | Pittsford Sutherland |
| Marla Woodarek (10) | Penfield | * | Kim Cufari (12) | Pittsford Sutherland |
| Julie Cass (9) | Fairport | * | Lauren Phillips (11) | Batavia |
| Christyna Cain (11) | Brockport | * | Amanda Wilcox (10) | Greece Arcadia |
| Hillary Snyder (9) | Fairport | * | Alicia Cheesbro (10) | Churchville Chili |
| Ashley Cocuzzi (9) | Webster Schroeder | * | Lauren Jencik (9) | Fairport |
| Emily Davis (9) | Brockport | * | Krystina Sylvester (12) | Rush Henrietta |